German shock at car exhaust tests on humans and monkeys



German shock at car exhaust tests on humans and monkeys

Share this with Facebook

Share this with Twitter

Share this with Messenger

Share this with Messenger

Share this with Email

Share

Share this with
These are external links and will open in a new window

Email
Share this with Email

Facebook
Share this with Facebook

Messenger
Share this with Messenger

Messenger
Share this with Messenger

Twitter
Share this with Twitter

Pinterest
Share this with Pinterest

WhatsApp
Share this with WhatsApp

LinkedIn
Share this with LinkedIn

Copy this link
Read more about sharing.
These are external links and will open in a new window

Image copyright
EPA

Image caption

German carmakers have already been hit by a damaging scandal over cheating in emissions tests

The German government has denounced experiments funded by German carmakers in which humans and monkeys reportedly inhaled diesel exhaust fumes.German media say the health impact research was done by EUGT, a body funded by Volkswagen, Daimler and BMW. Such tests could not be justified, the government said, demanding details. A minister called them “abominable”. Daimler also condemned them. VW is embroiled in a scandal over software that gave false diesel exhaust data.In 2015 VW admitted having fitted “cheat” devices in the US that made their engines appear less polluting than they actually were.
Image copyright
AFP

Image caption

Car firms are trying to reduce losses from bad publicity about diesel fumes

EUGT was dissolved by the carmakers last year. The initials stand for European Research Group on Environment and Health in the Transport Sector.”These tests on monkeys or even humans cannot be justified ethically in any way,” said Chancellor Angela Merkel’s spokesman, Steffen Seibert.Environment Minister Barbara Hendricks called the experiments “abominable” and expressed shock that scientists had agreed to conduct them.Social Democrat politician Stephan Weil – a VW supervisory board member – called them “absurd and abhorrent”. “Lobbying can be no excuse whatsoever for such testing,” he said.What do we know about the tests?On Thursday the New York Times reported that the EUGT research was designed to counter a 2012 decision by the World Health Organization to classify diesel exhaust as a carcinogen.It said that in 2014, EUGT had exposed 10 monkeys to fumes – in an air-tight chamber – from several cars, including a diesel VW Beetle. The testing took place at a lab in Albuquerque, New Mexico. Then at the weekend Germany’s Stuttgarter Zeitung and SWR radio reported that 19 men and six women had inhaled diesel fumes in another EUGT experiment.During a month of tests at a lab in Aachen, west Germany, they were exposed to various concentrations of diesel fumes, which contain toxic nitrogen oxides (NOx). The BBC has not seen the study itself, but German media say it was published in 2016.At the time the carmakers were arguing that modern technology had cut pollution from diesel engines to safe levels. But VW was later found to have fitted “cheat” devices that rigged the emissions data.Read more on the diesel emissions scandal:VW emissions cheat bill hits $30bn
How toxic is your car exhaust?
Volkswagen: The scandal explained
What have the carmakers said about this?Daimler, manufacturer of Mercedes-Benz cars, said on Sunday “we are appalled by the extent of the [EUGT] studies and their implementation”. “We condemn the experiments in the strongest terms.”Reacting to the NYT report about the monkey experiments, VW tweeted on Saturday that it “explicitly distances itself clearly from all forms of animal abuse”. “We know that the scientific methods used by EUGT were wrong and apologise sincerely for this.”VW’s supervisory board says it will conduct a full investigation, calling the experiments “utterly incomprehensible”.What is the latest on diesel pollution?A new study by a German car specialist, Ferdinand Dudenhöffer, says levels of pollution from diesel cars are still too high in 10 German cities, so the vehicles are likely to be banned from the pollution hotspots unless engines are upgraded. According to his research, vehicle software upgrades would not be enough to address the problem. Munich, Stuttgart, Hamburg, Düsseldorf and Cologne are among the cities with serious pollution hotspots.